One of the most overwhelming problems in American academia is the fact that at least 50% of the "students" enrolled in American colleges have absolutely no business being there. This is the result of the counterproductive myth that everyone needs and is entitled to a college education.
I'm sure there will be the standard responses about the democratization of higher education, that it's no longer the exclusive province of privileged rich kids, etc., etc. But if everyone gets a higher education, then what is "higher" about it any more? It becomes basic general education, like high school is supposed to be. Hmmm, maybe that's why college has indeed been dumbed down into nothing but glorified high school, if even that. Some of our foreign exchange students are flabbergasted at the Mickey-Mouse level of the classes they are taking here, as well as by the attitudes and behavior of American students.
Here's why many of our students shouldn't be in college:
- Some of them are stupid. I know it's horribly politically incorrect to point this out, but some people just ain't got it intellectually. For example, if after a full semester of foreign language you simply cannot grasp the concept of a direct object, you probably have no business in college. As a perplexed foreign exchange student put it after a few months here, "We have stupid people in my country too...but they don't go to college."
- Some of them are woefully ignorant and academically unprepared. We're talking borderline illiterate. Their reading comprehension is inadequate, and their writing skills are abysmal. And they think we fought against the Rooskies in WWII.
- Most importantly, many of them DON'T WANT TO BE HERE. Mommy and Daddy and society at large have coerced them into college even though they hate reading, hate writing, hate studying, and have precious little intellectual curiosity about anything (whence their loathing of gen ed requirements). And then we're surprised that they have hostile pissy attitudes and always want to take the path of least resistance? But if they don't go to college, they will never ever ever get a good job--so they've had drummed into them since they popped out of the womb. And, of course, job training is really what it's all about (well, let's leave that bugaboo for another missive). Yeah, right, like my brother-in-law the electrician who makes 50% more money than I do. A good plumber or carpenter or auto mechanic is worth his/her weight in gold, but all these kids are told they must go to college or they will spend their lives flipping burgers.
Why is this unfixable? Because it is a firmly entrenched systemic problem that has been many decades in the making. And, indeed, half of us would be out of jobs if American academia suddenly decided to impose and enforce actual standards. Half of the colleges in this country would have to close up shop, and that just ain't gonna happen. Instead, we commodify education and market ourselves and behave like competing corporations. In most countries students compete to get into college. In America colleges compete for students, the destructiveness of which (in terms of quality education) can hardly be overstated. The grand "everyone should go to college" myth keeps us all in business, pure and simple.